top of page

The Legal Process in Canada

Arrest

When you are arrested in Canada, understanding your rights and the appropriate actions to take is crucial. Here’s a detailed guide on what to expect and how to handle this situation.

  1. Arrest:

    • What Happens: An arrest occurs when law enforcement officials believe you have committed a crime. They will take you into custody and inform you that you are under arrest.

    • Your Rights: Upon arrest, you must be informed of the reason for your arrest. You have the right to remain silent and the right to speak to a lawyer without delay.

    • Do’s:

      • Stay Calm: Remain as calm and composed as possible.

      • Ask for Clarification: Politely ask the officer to clarify why you are being arrested if it is not clear.

      • Exercise Your Right to Remain Silent: Clearly state that you choose to remain silent and wish to speak to a lawyer.

      • Request a Lawyer: Immediately request to speak to a lawyer. You have the right to a private conversation with them.

      • Provide Basic Information: You may provide your name, address, and date of birth, but avoid giving any additional information or explanations.

    • Don’ts:

      • Do Not Resist Arrest: Do not physically resist, as this can lead to additional charges.

      • Do Not Make Any Statements: Do not say anything beyond basic information until you have spoken to your lawyer. Anything you say can be used against you in court.

      • Do Not Consent to Searches: Unless they have a warrant or it's a search incident to arrest, do not consent to any searches of your person or property.

  2. Booking:

    • What Happens: After the arrest, you will be taken to the police station for booking. This involves recording your personal information, taking fingerprints and photographs, and noting the charges against you.

    • Your Rights: During booking, you still have the right to remain silent and the right to legal counsel.

    • Do’s:

      • Cooperate with Fingerprinting and Photographing: Comply with the booking process, as resisting can result in further complications.

      • Reiterate Your Request for a Lawyer: If you have not yet spoken to a lawyer, ask to do so again.

    • Don’ts:

      • Do Not Answer Questions About the Incident: Continue to refrain from discussing the incident or charges with the police without your lawyer present.​​

Charges

Once you have been arrested and booked, the legal process moves to the charging stage. Here’s what you need to know:

  1. Initial Appearance:

    • What Happens: You will have an initial appearance before a judge in the Ontario Court of Justice. The judge will inform you of the charges against you and your rights. Bail may be discussed.

    • Your Rights: You have the right to be informed of the charges and to legal representation.

    • Do’s:

      • Listen Carefully: Pay attention to the charges being read and the conditions of your bail, if applicable.

      • Communicate with Your Lawyer: Ensure your lawyer is present and understands the charges against you.

      • Follow Bail Conditions: If bail is granted, strictly adhere to all conditions set by the court.

    • Don’ts:

      • Do Not Make Any Statements About the Case: Do not discuss the details of your case with anyone other than your lawyer.

  2. Types of Charges:

    • Summary Offences: Less serious crimes, such as minor theft or causing a disturbance. These are typically tried in the Ontario Court of Justice without a jury.

    • Indictable Offences: More serious crimes, such as robbery or murder. Depending on the offence, these may be tried in the Superior Court of Justice and can involve a preliminary inquiry and a trial by judge or jury.

    • Hybrid Offences: These can be prosecuted as either summary or indictable, at the discretion of the Crown prosecutor.

    • Do’s:

      • Understand the Nature of Your Charges: Make sure you understand whether your charges are summary, indictable, or hybrid, as this affects the legal process.

      • Discuss Strategy with Your Lawyer: Work closely with your lawyer to plan your defense based on the type of charges.

    • Don’ts:

      • Do Not Attempt to Handle Complex Legal Matters Alone: Always seek legal advice, especially with indictable or hybrid offences.

Trial

After the initial stages of arrest and charges, the next significant phase in the legal process is the trial. Understanding what happens during a trial and how to navigate this phase is crucial. Here’s a detailed guide on the trial process in Canada:

  1. Pre-Trial Motions:

    • What Happens: Before the trial begins, both the defence and prosecution can file pre-trial motions. These are requests made to the court to decide on specific issues, such as excluding certain evidence or dismissing the case.

    • Your Rights: You have the right to have your lawyer file motions on your behalf and argue them in court.

    • Do’s:

      • Work with Your Lawyer: Discuss any potential pre-trial motions with your lawyer and understand their implications.

      • Be Honest with Your Lawyer: Provide all relevant information to your lawyer to help them make informed decisions about pre-trial motions.

    • Don’ts:

      • Do Not Miss Court Dates: Ensure you attend all pre-trial hearings as required.

      • Do Not Discuss Your Case Publicly: Avoid discussing the details of your case with anyone other than your lawyer.

  2. The Trial Process:

    • What Happens: The trial itself involves presenting evidence and arguments in court to determine your guilt or innocence. Trials can be conducted by a judge alone or by a judge and jury, depending on the nature of the charges.

    • Opening Statements:

      • Prosecution: The Crown prosecutor presents an overview of the case against you.

      • Defence: Your lawyer provides an overview of your defence.

    • Presentation of Evidence:

      • Prosecution’s Case: The prosecution presents evidence and calls witnesses to testify against you.

      • Cross-Examination: Your lawyer can cross-examine the prosecution’s witnesses to challenge their testimony.

      • Defence’s Case: Your lawyer presents evidence and calls witnesses to testify on your behalf.

    • Closing Arguments:

      • Prosecution: Summarizes the evidence and argues why you should be found guilty.

      • Defence: Summarizes the evidence and argues why you should be found not guilty.

    • Jury Instructions (if applicable): If the trial involves a jury, the judge will provide instructions on how to deliberate and apply the law to the facts.

    • Your Rights: You have the right to a fair trial, to present evidence in your defence, and to be presumed innocent until proven guilty beyond a reasonable doubt.

    • Do’s:

      • Follow Your Lawyer’s Advice: Trust and follow the guidance of your lawyer throughout the trial.

      • Be Honest and Clear: If you testify, be truthful and clear in your responses.

      • Remain Respectful: Show respect to the court, the judge, and all participants in the trial.

    • Don’ts:

      • Do Not Interrupt Proceedings: Avoid any disruptions during the trial; maintain a respectful demeanor.

      • Do Not Contact Witnesses: Do not attempt to contact or influence witnesses outside of the courtroom.

Verdict

After the trial concludes, the next step is reaching a verdict. Here’s what happens:

  1. Deliberation:

    • What Happens: If your trial is by jury, the jury will deliberate in private to reach a verdict. If your trial is by judge alone, the judge will consider the evidence and make a decision.

    • Your Rights: You have the right to a verdict based on the evidence presented during the trial.

    • Do’s:

      • Wait Patiently: Understand that deliberations can take time. Remain patient and composed.

      • Communicate with Your Lawyer: Stay in contact with your lawyer for updates and advice.

    • Don’ts:

      • Do Not Try to Influence the Jury: Avoid any attempts to contact or influence jury members.

  2. The Verdict:

    • What Happens: The jury or judge will announce the verdict in court, determining whether you are guilty or not guilty.

    • Your Rights: You have the right to hear the verdict and receive an explanation of the decision.

    • Do’s:

      • Listen Carefully: Pay close attention to the verdict and any statements made by the judge.

      • Follow Your Lawyer’s Guidance: Your lawyer will advise you on the next steps, whether the verdict is guilty or not guilty.

    • Don’ts:

      • Do Not React Disruptively: Regardless of the verdict, remain calm and composed in court.

      • Do Not Speak Out of Turn: Wait for your lawyer or the judge to indicate when it is appropriate to speak.

  3. Post-Verdict Actions:

    • Guilty Verdict: If found guilty, you will proceed to the sentencing phase where the judge will determine your punishment. Your lawyer can argue for a fair and appropriate sentence.

    • Not Guilty Verdict: If found not guilty, you are free to leave, and the charges are dismissed.

    • Do’s:

      • Prepare for Sentencing: If found guilty, work with your lawyer to prepare for the sentencing hearing.

      • Consider an Appeal: If you believe there were errors in the trial, discuss with your lawyer the possibility of filing an appeal.

    • Don’ts:

      • Do Not Delay: Act promptly on any decisions regarding appeals or other post-verdict actions.

Sentencing

After a guilty verdict, the next phase in the legal process is sentencing. Understanding what happens during sentencing and how to navigate this phase is crucial. Here’s a detailed guide on the sentencing process in Canada:

  1. Pre-Sentencing Report:

    • What Happens: A pre-sentencing report may be prepared by a probation officer. This report includes information about your background, character, and the circumstances of the offence. It helps the judge determine an appropriate sentence.

    • Your Rights: You have the right to review the pre-sentencing report and address any inaccuracies with your lawyer.

    • Do’s:

      • Cooperate with Probation Officer: Provide accurate information to the probation officer during the interview.

      • Review the Report: Carefully review the pre-sentencing report with your lawyer to ensure its accuracy.

    • Don’ts:

      • Do Not Provide False Information: Do not mislead or provide false information to the probation officer, as this can negatively impact your sentencing.

  2. Sentencing Hearing:

    • What Happens: The sentencing hearing is where the judge decides your punishment based on the crime's nature, the pre-sentencing report, and any mitigating or aggravating factors.

    • Your Rights: You have the right to be present at the sentencing hearing, to present evidence or statements on your behalf, and to have your lawyer argue for a fair sentence.

    • Do’s:

      • Prepare a Statement: If appropriate, prepare a statement to express remorse, explain your actions, or provide context to the judge.

      • Follow Your Lawyer’s Advice: Work with your lawyer to present mitigating factors that might reduce your sentence, such as lack of prior criminal record, remorse, or efforts at rehabilitation.

      • Attend Sentencing: Be present at your sentencing hearing and show respect to the court.

    • Don’ts:

      • Do Not Interrupt: Do not interrupt the proceedings. Allow your lawyer to speak on your behalf.

      • Do Not Display Disrespect: Avoid showing disrespect or contempt, as this can negatively influence the judge’s decision.

  3. Types of Sentences:

    • Fines: Monetary penalties paid to the court.

    • Probation: Supervised release with conditions you must follow.

    • Community Service: Unpaid work benefiting the community.

    • Imprisonment: Incarceration in a correctional facility.

    • Conditional Sentences: Serving a sentence in the community under strict conditions, often involving house arrest.

    • Restitution: Compensating victims for their losses.

    • Do’s:

      • Understand the Sentence: Ensure you fully understand the terms of your sentence, including any conditions you must follow.

      • Comply with Conditions: Strictly adhere to all conditions of your sentence to avoid further legal issues.

    • Don’ts:

      • Do Not Violate Probation or Conditions: Violating the terms of your sentence can lead to additional charges and harsher penalties.

Appeal

If you believe there were legal errors in your trial or sentencing, you have the right to appeal. Here’s what you need to know about the appeal process in Canada:

  1. Grounds for Appeal:

    • What Happens: An appeal is not a retrial but a review of the trial process for legal errors. Common grounds for appeal include errors in the application of the law, procedural mistakes, or new evidence that could significantly affect the outcome.

    • Your Rights: You have the right to appeal a conviction, sentence, or both.

    • Do’s:

      • Consult with Your Lawyer: Discuss with your lawyer whether there are valid grounds for an appeal.

      • File Promptly: Appeals must be filed within a specific time frame after sentencing, usually 30 days. Ensure you file your notice of appeal promptly.

    • Don’ts:

      • Do Not Delay: Do not wait until the last minute to decide on an appeal. Timeliness is crucial.

  2. Filing an Appeal:

    • What Happens: To initiate an appeal, you or your lawyer must file a notice of appeal with the appropriate appellate court. The notice outlines the grounds for your appeal.

    • Your Rights: You have the right to be represented by a lawyer during the appeal process and to have the appellate court review your case.

    • Do’s:

      • Prepare Thoroughly: Work with your lawyer to prepare a strong argument for your appeal.

      • Gather Evidence: Collect any new evidence or documentation that supports your grounds for appeal.

    • Don’ts:

      • Do Not Overlook Details: Ensure all necessary documents are filed correctly and on time.

  3. The Appeal Process:

    • What Happens: The appellate court will review the trial record, written arguments (briefs) from both sides, and may hear oral arguments. The court will then decide whether to uphold the original decision, overturn it, or order a new trial.

    • Your Rights: You have the right to a fair review of your case by the appellate court.

    • Do’s:

      • Attend Hearings: If required, attend appeal hearings and follow your lawyer’s advice during these proceedings.

      • Be Prepared: Ensure you and your lawyer are well-prepared to present your case to the appellate court.

    • Don’ts:

      • Do Not Assume Immediate Relief: Understand that the appeal process can be lengthy and complex. Be patient and persistent.

  4. Possible Outcomes:

    • Upholding the Conviction: The appellate court may decide that the original decision was correct and uphold the conviction and sentence.

    • Overturning the Conviction: The appellate court may find errors that warrant overturning the conviction, which could result in acquittal or a new trial.

    • Ordering a New Trial: If significant errors are found, the court may order a new trial.

    • Adjusting the Sentence: The appellate court may also adjust the sentence if it was deemed inappropriate.

    • Do’s:

      • Understand the Outcome: Make sure you understand the appellate court’s decision and its implications for your case.

      • Plan Next Steps: Work with your lawyer to plan any further actions, such as preparing for a new trial if ordered.

    • Don’ts:

      • Do Not Give Up: If the appeal is not successful, discuss other legal options with your lawyer.

bottom of page